| Home | E-Submission | Sitemap | Editorial Office |  
J Minim Invasive Spine Surg Tech > Volume 10(2); 2025 > Article
Kaen, Quillo-Olvera, Park, and Durand: Is the Ipsilateral Endoscopic Approach Better for Large Synovial Cysts?

Abstract

This report presents a case of a patient with a large synovial cyst treated using a biportal endoscopic ipsilateral approach. Synovial cysts are dilatations of synovial sheaths arising from the zygapophyseal joint capsule. Surgical resection of the cyst and decompression of the neural structures remain the preferred treatment. The size of a cyst is directly proportional to the strength of its attachment to the capsule and dura; thus, larger cysts exhibit a broader area of adhesion between the cyst wall and the dura. The contralateral endoscopic approach has gained popularity for small cysts due to its ability to preserve the facet joint and facilitate cyst dissection. However, larger cysts, which adhere more firmly to the dura, pose greater technical challenges for dissection via the contralateral route. We describe a case of a large synovial cyst successfully treated with a biportal endoscopic ipsilateral approach. A 62-year-old man presented with left leg radicular pain (L5 root) and severe neurogenic intermittent claudication. Preoperative magnetic resonance imaging revealed a large left L4–5 synovial cyst causing severe central canal stenosis. Complete resection was achieved using the ipsilateral unilateral biportal endoscopic technique. Postoperative magnetic resonance imaging confirmed adequate decompression without complications. The patient’s symptoms resolved immediately after surgery, and no spinal instability was observed 1 year postoperatively. The endoscopic biportal ipsilateral approach represents a viable and effective option for the treatment of synovial cysts, particularly those of large size.

CASE REPORT

A 62-year-old male patient presented with persistent left L5 radicular pain affecting his mobility for several months. The patient reported mild lumbar pain and no complaints of sphincter abnormalities. However, in the last week he has experienced severe neurological claudication. Physical examination did not reveal any motor deficits. The preoperative lumbar magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) shows an intracanal cyst (21 mm × 14 mm ×12 mm) with a thick capsule and heterogeneous contents (Figure 1). The cyst has a considerable impact on the thecal sac, resulting in a notable narrowing of the central canal. A complete resection was performed using the ipsilateral unilateral biportal endoscopy (UBE) technique under general anaesthesia.
The procedure was conducted from the patient's left side. Once 2 ports have been created (cranial endoscopic portal/caudal working portal; Figure 2), the relevant anatomical references in the L4–5 space have been identified (Supplementary Video Clip 1). The initial step is to drill the inferior edge of the superior lamina until the upper insertion of the ligamentum flavum can be identified. This crucial step serves a dual purpose: it facilitates the detachment of the ligament and allows sufficient space for the endoscopic camera movement during cyst dissection. The second step is to detach the ligamentum flavum at the caudal insertions (upper lamina of the lower vertebra). Subsequently, the ligamentum flavum is dissected in a systematic manner, from cranial to caudal and from medial to lateral, in order to identify any adhesions to the dura and the epidural veins. In view of the dimensions of the cyst, we have elected to open the cyst wall and perform an intracyst resection while maintaining the capsule (debulking). This procedure will reduce the pressure exerted by the cyst wall on the healthy dura mater, thereby facilitating a more accurate dissection. The cyst was successfully removed without any complications. To reduce the risk of recurrence, the edges of the capsule attached to the dura mater were coagulated using a radiofrequency probe set at the minimal effective power settings under continuous saline irrigation. This method aims to shrink the remaining wall of the cyst while ensuring thermal protection for the adjacent neural structures. The patient was discharged from the hospital within 24 hours. A postoperative MRI was performed, confirming the correct decompression and the absence of surgical complications (Figure 3). The patient experienced an immediate resolution of symptoms. One year after the procedure, no instability sign was observed.

DISCUSSION

Synovial cysts are dilations of synovial sheaths that originate in the zygapophyseal joint capsule of the lumbar spine [1]. The exact cause of facet cysts is not fully understood, but it is believed to be associated with joint destabilization due to degenerative or traumatic changes in the ligamentum flavum and the facet joints. The prevalence ranges from 0.5% to 1.1% in older studies [2]. However, with the improved diagnostic possibilities of MRI, the number of identified cysts has increased to 5.8% in recent decades [3]. They are mostly found in the lumbar spine, particularly at the L4–5 level, and can cause symptoms such as neurogenic claudication, radiculopathy, or even cauda equina syndrome. These cysts can be classified as either a true synovial cyst or a pseudo-cyst [4]. A true synovial cyst is characterized by a visible connection between the joint and the cyst on the MRI, while a pseudo-cyst, like a ganglion, does not show this relationship [5,6]. It is important to note that this cyst often exhibits a strong tendency to adhere to the dura. In some cases, the inflammatory changes observed in the capsule can present a significant challenge in differentiating it from the true dura.
Several surgical options are available for treating cysts, including conservative management, corticosteroid injection, percutaneous cyst rupture aspiration and surgical excision with or without fusion [1,7-10]. However, conservative and percutaneous therapies may not provide long-lasting effects [3,6]. Resection of the cyst and decompression of neural structures is the preferred method of treatment as it can lead to immediate and long-lasting improvement of symptoms.
UBE represents a novel technique employed for the treatment of a range of spinal disorders [7,8]. UBE surgery is particularly efficacious in the decompression of lumbar juxta-synovial cysts [1]. It provides a clear, magnified surgical view from the ipsilateral to the contralateral side, thereby rendering it an optimal choice even for those new to endoscopic surgery. UBE may result in superior clinical outcomes, including reduced muscle damage, diminished postoperative opioid use, and shorter hospital stays in comparison to microscopic decompression [7].
It is crucial to consider a number of factors when determining the most appropriate endoscopic surgical approach [4,9,11]. It is somewhat surprising that the size of the cyst has not been taken into account previously in order to decide the best approach, given its potential impact on the surgical strategy. It is incontestable that the volume of the cyst correlates with the strength of its attachment to the capsule and dura. A greater volume will result in a larger area of attachment between the cyst wall and the dura. While there is no exact definition of the size at which cysts should be considered small or large, some authors have assessed the impact of cysts on the spinal canal. Campbell et al. [5] established a classification system for these cysts, categorising them into three types based on the percentage of canal stenosis: less than 25%, 25%–50%, or more than 50%. In the case of small cysts, the contralateral endoscopic approach is becoming increasingly popular due to its ability to facilitate facet joint preservation and simplify cyst dissection [1]. However, larger cysts have a greater volume adhered with the dura, making them more difficult to dissect. Surgeons should be aware that this requires more experience, planning, and dissection skills. An ipsilateral approach could be an alternative as we show in this case. The ipsilateral approach in large cysts allows for the debulking of the cyst in the early stage, which helps reduce the mass effect on the dura and guide the surgeon in identifying the cyst wall. This may contribute to reducing the tractions during the dissection and the risk of dural tear (Table 1).
The video provided by the authors offers an excellent illustration of the surgical technique for the removal of a large synovial cyst using an ipsilateral endoscopic approach, which avoids dura retraction and the risk of damaging surrounding nervous structures. However, further prospective randomized studies are required to obtain more precise conclusions.

WRITTEN TRANSCRIPT

0:00 Title Page

Is the ipsilateral endoscopic approach better for large synovial cysts?

0:05 Introduction

Introduction. The synovial cyst was first described by Dr Baker in 1885 as a synovial formation adjacent to the joint. The exact aetiology of spinal synovial cysts is still unclear. They have been known by several names, including ganglion, juxtasynovial cyst, and syphmos, which are the most common.

1:06 Definitions

There are 2 different types of cysts in the lumbar spine. The true synovial cyst is where we can identify connections between the cyst and the facet joint. And a nonsynovial cyst or pseudocyst where there is no direct relationship between the facet and the cyst.
The true synovial cyst can dissect the anterior part of the capsular facet joint and enter into the lumbar canal. Sometimes, the capsule herniation is posterior and only causes lumbar pain. Nonsynovial cysts are various types of cysts found along the spine. The most common types include ganglion cysts with mucinous content, ligament flavum cysts, and posterior longitudinal ligament cysts.

1:14 Epidemiology

Lumbar synovial cyst epidemiology. It is most frequent in the sixth decade of life and is slightly more common in females. They are usually located at the L4–5 level, likely due to their high mobility. Synovial cysts are found equally on both sides of the spine and can be found at two or more levels in one patient.

1:40 Pathogenesis

Related to the pathogenesis The synovial cyst is characterised by a wall lined with synovial cells containing clear and xanthochromic fluid. Some authors suggest that degeneration of the cyst and prolonged involvement of the capsule may cause it to detach from the facet joint, leading to it being referred to as a ganglion. Although the ganglion cyst does not have an epithelium similar to the synovium, it could be a late stage of the synovial cyst that has become disconnected from the facet.

2:06 Clinical Presentations

Synovial cysts may be asymptomatic and found incidentally. However, most of the patients complain of back pain. The most frequent symptom is radicular pain, which occurs in over 90% of patients. Neurologic claudication are present in almost all cases at the time of diagnosis.

2:25 Endoscopic Treatment

There are different treatment options, however endoscopic procedures are the best options in last year. It is important to remember that this cyst tends to strongly adhere to the dura and sometimes the inflammatory changes of the capsule make it very difficult to differentiate from the real dura. In the case of small cysts, the contralateral approach has gained popularity due to its facilitation of facet joint preservation and simplified cyst dissection.
A contralateral approach is possible even in cases of large cysts. However, surgeons should be aware that this requires more experience, planning and dissection skills. An ipsilateral approach could be a suitable alternative. But treating from the ipsilateral side allows for initial debulking of the cyst, reducing its volume and enabling dissection without pushing the dura.

3:18 Case Presentations

Here we present a patient with a large cyst treated using an endoscopic biportal ipsilateral approach. A 62-year-old male patient presented with L5 radicular pain in his left leg. The symptoms had been noted for several months and he had difficulty walking because of the pain. He exhibited severe neurological intermittent claudication. The preoperative MRI reveals an intracanal cyst with thick capsulate and heterogeneous contents. The cyst has a significant mass effect on the thecal sac. A biportal endoscopic ipsilateral approach was performed.

3:57 Surgical Steps. Step 1

Remember that always the left side of the screen is cranial and the upper part of the video is medial. The first step begins with the ipsilateral laminotomy. This is a critical step that involves drilling the lower edge of the upper vertebra until the upper limit of the flavum ligament is visible. It is essential to note that this drilling not only detaches the flavum ligament but also creates space for the endoscope camera in the upcoming steps.

4:33 Step 2

The second step consists of removing the flavum ligament at the lower attachments. Kerrison rounger or osteotome can be used. A dissection of the flavum ligament was performed from cranial to caudal and from middle line to lateral in order to gain a better understanding of the attachment of the cyst to the dura. It should be noted that the cyst wall has a appearance to the dura and is usually strongly adhered.
In this case, due to its size, we plan to open the cyst and perform a significant debulking as we would with a tumour. This should help to reduce the contact between the cyst and the dura.

5:21 Step 3. Debulking

The debulking begins at the most posterior section near the ipsilateral facet joint. Reducing the content of the cyst helps clarify the complex anatomy between the dura and the cyst wall.

5:57 Step 4. Dissections the Cyst

Following the intracyst debulking procedure, the cyst was carefully dissected. The inferior attachment was first separated, followed by the upper part of the cyst. Due to the presence of adhesions with the dura, maintaining the dura without causing damage was challenging. Try to find a plane between the dura and cyst. Not always we can remove complete the capsule from the cyst.

6:41 Check the Remaining Capsule and Postoperative MRI

It is highly recommended that you regularly check the remaining cyst capsule and coagulated in order to reduce the risk of recurrence. The postoperative MRI demonstrates successful decompression without any complications in both the axial and sagittal images. This indicates a positive outcome and confirms the efficacy of the procedure.

7:03 Discussion

It's important to consider several factors when deciding on a surgical approach. Surprisingly, the size of the cyst has not been taken into account before. The volume of the cyst is definitely related to how firmly it is attached to the capsule and the dura.
In the case of small cysts, using a contralateral approach not only allows for the dissection of the cyst but also preserves the facet joint. The large cyst has a greater volume and is attached to the dura, which makes it more challenging to dissect. The ipsilateral approach allows for early debulking of the cyst, aiding the surgeon in identifying the cyst wall and its close relationship to the dura mater.

7:41 Conclusion

Conclusion. Endoscopic biportal ipsilateral approach could be a good option in patients with synovial cysts, especially in large ones. More studies need to be conducted to make strong recommendations.

NOTES

Conflicts of interest

The authors have nothing to disclose.

Funding/Support

This study received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

Informed Consent

Informed consent was obtained from the patient for the use of their data and images in this study.

Figure 1.
Preoperative magnetic resonance imaging reveals a large intracanal cyst (21 mm × 14 mm × 12 mm) with a thick capsule and heterogeneous contents. The cyst exerted a significant mass effect on the thecal sac (sagittal, A; axial, B).
jmisst-2025-02509f1.jpg
Figure 2.
(A) Intraoperative anteroposterior C-arm fluoroscopic images show the planned portals: docking point at the spinolaminar junctions (star), working portal (W), and endoscopic portal (E) along the medial pedicular line. (B) The correct triangulations should always be verified before drilling.
jmisst-2025-02509f2.jpg
Figure 3.
Postoperative magnetic resonance images show complete cyst removal and correct decompression (sagittal, A; axial, B).
jmisst-2025-02509f3.jpg
Table 1.
Endoscopic approaches for synovial cysts (based on size and adhesion)
Approach Contralateral approach Ipsilateral approach
Primary indication Small/medium cysts Large cysts
Access point Opposite to the cyst Directly over the cyst
Facet joint preservation ++ +
Risk of dural injury in large cyst ++ +
Technical complexity + +
 Small cyst ++ +
 Big cyst
Surgical management of the cyst Direct detachment of dura mater, without early debulking Early debulking/mass reduction, and then identification of the cyst wall

+, less; ++, more.

REFERENCES

1. Heo DH, Kim JS, Park CW, Quillo-Olvera J, Park CK. Contralateral sublaminar endoscopic approach for removal of lumbar juxtafacet cysts using percutaneous biportal endoscopic surgery: technical report and preliminary results. World Neurosurg 2019;122:474–9.
crossref pmid
2. Ikuta K, Tono O, Oga M. Prevalence and clinical features of intraspinal facet cysts after decompression surgery for lumbar spinal stenosis. J Neurosurg Spine 2009;10:617–22.
crossref pmid
3. Ganga A, Leary OP, Setty A, Xi K, Telfeian A, Oyelese A, et al. Optimizing surgical management of facet cysts of the lumbar spine: systematic review, meta-analysis, and local case series of 1251 patients. J Neurosurg Spine 2023;39:793–806.
crossref pmid
4. Bruder M, Cattani A, Gessler F, Droste C, Setzer M, Seifert V, et al. Synovial cysts of the spine: long-term follow-up after surgical treatment of 141 cases in a single-center series and comprehensive literature review of 2900 degenerative spinal cysts. J Neurosurg Spine 2017;27:256–67.
crossref pmid
5. Campbell R, Phan K, Mobbs R. Classification of lumbar facet joint cysts using the NeuroSpine Surgery Research Group (NSURG) Grading score and correlation with recurrence and clinical outcomes. World Neurosurg 2018;119:e502–12.
crossref pmid
6. Campbell RJ, Mobbs RJ, Rao PJ, Phan K. Interventions for lumbar synovial facet joint cysts: a comparison of percutaneous, surgical decompression and fusion approaches. World Neurosurg 2017;98:492–502.
crossref pmid
7. Kaen A, Park MK, Son SK. Clinical outcomes of uniportal compared with biportal endoscopic decompression for the treatment of lumbar spinal stenosis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur Spine J 2023;32:2717–25.
crossref pmid pdf
8. Kaen A, Quillo-Olvera J, Park MK, Rocha S, Durand F, Martin I, et al. Five-step unilateral biportal endoscopic surgery for central lumbar canal stenosis: "Z" technique nuance. Neurosurg Focus Video 2024;10:V3.
crossref pmid pmc
9. Page PS, Parmar V, Momin E, Burkett DJ, Greeneway GP, Hanna A, et al. Classification and reliability of lumbar facet cysts grading scales. World Neurosurg 2021;155:e391–4.
crossref pmid
10. Rosenstock T, Vajkoczy P. New classification of facet joint synovial cysts. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 2020;162:929–36.
crossref pmid pdf
11. Hellinger S, Lewandrowski KU. Clinical outcomes with endoscopic resection of lumbar extradural cysts. J Spine Surg 2020;6(Suppl 1):S133–44.
crossref pmid pmc
About |  Browse Articles |  Editorial Policy |  For Contributors
Editorial Office
Department of Neurosurgery, Harrison Spinartus Hospital Chungdam
646 Samseong-ro, Gangnam-gu, Seoul 06084, Korea
TEL: +82-2-6003-9767    FAX: +82-2-3445-9755   E-mail: office@jmisst.org
Publisher
Korean Minimally Invasive Spine Surgery Society
350 Seocho-daero, Seocho-gu, Seoul 06631, Korea
TEL: +82-2-585-5455    FAX: +82-2-523-6812   E-mail: komisskomiss@komiss.org
Copyright © Korean Minimally Invasive Spine Surgery Society.                 Developed in M2PI